|
Update Article
|
The Hong Kong Practitioner
VOLUME 25 / October 2003
|
|
|
|
| The interesting phenomenon
of sexual deviations and perversions |
| Summary Sexual behaviour is broadly divided into sexual functions and sexual practices. A normal sexual practice is difficult to define and is also affected by the current social norms. Paraphilias or sexual deviations (formerly called perversions) form a special category with the characteristic feature of sexual arousal in response to an inappropriate sexual stimulus, and may interfere with the capacity to establish sexual relationships. Such behaviours may be harmless or injurious, physically or psychologically, and can become sexual offences in the absence of consent. The true prevalence rate is unknown, and milder forms are not detected. Treatment is not easily achieved, and recidivism is high. Psychological and medical therapies have been tried, and a comprehensive approach including legal considerations, appears most promising. |
摘要
HK Pract 2003;25:491-502 |
| K Y Mak, MBBS(HK), MD(HK), MHA,
FRCPsych Correspondence to : |
Introduction Abnormal sexual behaviour is broadly divided into abnormal sexual functions and abnormal sexual practices. Throughout history, such abnormal sexual behaviours were often censored by the society and regarded as sinful, immoral, unnatural or even wicked and deserving punishment rather than treatment. Yet different cultures have different standards for normal sexual behaviour. While ancient Judaism condemned homosexuality, bestiality, transvestism and even masturbation, the Greeks culture was more tolerant to the extent that sex between an adult male and a "young boy" was seen as a form of respectable education.1 Sexual activities with animals and sexual interest in corpses were recorded in Buddhist texts over 2000 years ago. Sexual perversions became a scientific discipline of study in the late nineteenth century when Richard von Kraft-Ebing published the first masterpiece Psychopathia Sexualis in 1887. In this book, the author described fetishism, flagellation, sadism, necrophilia and other abnormal sexual behaviour. In 1918, Magnus Hirschfeld founded the Institute of Sexual Science in Berlin, Germany to study human sexuality especially that of sexual anomalies including homosexuality. Other prominent sexologists included Henry Havelock Ellis in the United Kingdom and Alfred Kinsey and his colleagues of the United States. Changing social attitudes and social movements especially feminism and sexual liberation modified the types of sexual deviations considered as such. In 1973, the Gay Liberation groups protested to the American Psychiatric Association, resulting in the deletion of homosexuality from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Nowadays, serious problems concerning various aspects of sexuality do occur. They are now more noticeable and likely to be reported by the mass media, especially that of child prostitution, sexual abuse and sexual harassment. Some are associated with criminal charges e.g. teachers molesting school children and are often headlines in the newspapers. |
Definitions In the past, various types of sexual behaviour have been labelled as sexual deviations. In fact historically, the term "sexual deviation" was preceded by that of "sexual perversion", both of which denote a sense of right and wrong, good and bad. According to Bancroft,2 sexual deviation denotes "any sexual behaviour which is socially unacceptable, stigmatised, and in many instances legally prohibited". To be more specific, Scott3 defined it as "a sexual act or fantasy other than genital intercourse with a consenting partner of the opposite sex of similar sexual maturity and acceptable blood relationships, and such behaviour is frequently repeated, contrary to cultural norms". With the changing morality in Western countries, the term "sexual deviation" is sometimes changed to "sexual variations" instead. According to de Silva,4 it refers to "sexual desires and behaviours outside what is considered to be the normal range". In the U.S., the neutral term "paraphilias" (meaning deviated attractions) is used, and is defined as recurrent, intense sexually arousing fantasies, sexual urges, or behaviours generally involving 1) non-human objects, 2) the suffering or humiliation of oneself or one's partner, or 3) children or other non-consenting persons, that occur over a period of at least 6 months. To qualify fully for such a diagnosis, there should be clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational or other important areas of functioning. |
| Prevalence
The prevalence of sexually deviated behaviour is difficult to ascertain. For one thing, it depends on the degree of reportability of cases. Sadomasochistic fantasies, for example, will probably never be reported. On the other hand, child molestation is reported in increasing frequency, perhaps with better awareness and social concern. For example, in the U.S., among all maltreated children only 9% were that of sexual abuse in 1983;5 but this increased to 16% in 1986. Clinical records are helpful but may not reflect the true extent of the situation. Perhaps those activities with criminal implication can be more clearly defined, but again it depends very much on the police detection rate (detectability) which often depends on the honesty of the criminals' stories and the reliability of the victims' testimonies. Nevertheless, it should be stated clearly that not all sexual deviations are crimes, and there are usually no psychotic symptoms exhibited. Therefore, the patients should not be stigmatised as criminals or lunatics. In the U.K., sexual offences account for 1% of all indictable crimes, and the percentage clear-up rate is 75%. However, recidivism can be as high as over 50%.6 Hospital or clinic records could give some estimates, but again they may represent a selected sub-group (recordability). Abel et al7 analysed (confidentiality assured) sex offenders against children coming for evaluation at the out-patient setting and recorded the average number of assaults per offender (Table 1). The results proved a gross under-reporting of such assaults in police records. Population survey is expensive and not practical, as such intimate questions are famous for inaccurate answers. The most famous national survey was that by Kinsey and his colleagues,8,9 but the report was criticised for under-recognition of sexual child abuse. And figures quoted in studies in the West cannot be extrapolated to other cultures, because of the importance of socio-cultural variables. For example, it is very likely that there is under-reporting of sexual abuses among Chinese societies, as sexual taboos are strong and family secrets are strongly hidden. As regards individual sexually deviated disorder, there is a great variation in the prevalence rate and the socio-demographic data of the perpetrator and the victims from one another. |
| Table 1: Frequency of assaults of child molesters |
||||||||||||||
|
Classification There is still no satisfactory classification of sexual deviations to-date, and a person may progress from one form to another. At one time in history, oral sex was considered a sexually perverted behaviour.10 Homosexuality was removed from the psychiatric classification only a few decades ago. Likewise, societal censored behaviour like adultery, premarital sex, concubines, etc. are not included as sexual deviations. In the first edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-I) of the American Psychiatric Association, Sexual Deviations were listed under the heading of "Sociopathic Personality Disturbance" which was within the category of "Personality Disorders". In the 2nd edition (DSM-II), Sexual Deviations became an entity of its own, and the term Paraphilia started to appear in DSM-III. According to the DSM-IV, the disorders under Paraphilia are slightly modified, and are listed below (Table 2), and it is not unusual for a person to have more than one paraphilia. |
| Table 2: Paraphilias according to DSM-IV |
|
|
Clinically speaking, the majority of paraphilics could have sex without fantasies, and deviant sexual behaviour can occur together with non-deviated sex. Furthermore, paraphilics often engage in different types of deviated sexual behaviours. Finally, the DSM-IV here did not take into account the criminal sexual intent as in rape. In the U.K. clinic setting, the more common disorders were fetishism, transvestism, sadism and masochism.4 From a social point of view, the following grouping is easier to understand. |
||
| A. | Acceptable sexual activity in inappropriate places | |
|
Such behaviours are usually
quite normal if performed in private, but become offensive to many people
if done in public, and are labelled as "indecent exposure", example of
which are: |
||
| 1. | Masturbation and self-exploration of the
body, especially of the genitalia; |
|
| 2. | Stripping (disrobing) especially genital
exposure; and |
|
| 3. | Urination, thereby exposing the genitals.
|
|
| B. | Culturally-determined acceptable sexual behaviour | |
| Such behaviour can be quite
normal in certain races or cultures, but become taboos in others. Examples
of such unlawful sexual acts (either homosexual or heterosexual) are:
|
||
| 1. | Sexual relationship with other residents
or inmates in an institution (especially if the other party is a minor);
|
|
| 2. | Sexual relationship with staff or subordinates
(including teacher-student and doctor-patient relationship). |
|
| The sexual act can either
be active or passive. If there is any monetary transaction for the act,
it can be charged as either soliciting material gain (usually the female
party) or prostitution (mostly the male party). |
||
| C. | Unacceptable sexual behaviour | |
| These are often acts involving
inappropriate sexual stimuli or non-consenting partners: |
||
| 1. | Indecent assault | |
| 2. | Rape | |
| 3. | Voyeurism (peeping-Tom) | |
| 4. | Paedophilia (gross indecency with children) | |
| 5. | Fetishism and transvestism | |
| 6. | Sado-masochism | |
| 7. | Obscene language | |
| Aetiology Most people can and do have some kind of perverted sexual fantasies, but they do not act them out. Why do a few individuals who are consumed by these fantasies act out, even infringing on the human rights of another person? Different types of sexual deviations can have different causes, but each one usually occurs as a result of a combination of biological, psychological and social factors. |
||
| A. | Biological | |
| 1. | Genetic: since most paraphilics are male,
many have thought that the Y chromosome should have an important role
to play. So far, only the XXY (Kleinfelter Syndrome) had been associated
with an increased rate of sexual deviation. Nielsen11 found
that among 411 subjects with XXY chromosome, 15 (3.6%) were homosexuals,
10 (2.4%) transvestites, 8 (1.9%) paedophiles, and 2 (0.5%) other sexual
perversions. Nevertheless, there is still a possibility that the gender
role and identity-development after birth having an influence on these
incomplete males and the attitudes of their parents towards them as "sons"
could have contributed to such deviated behaviour. |
|
| 2. | Hormonal: testosterone has been associated
with aggressive behaviour (including sexual), but clear-cut correlations
are lacking. Rada12 found that the testosterone levels were
higher among violent rapists, compared to that of child molesters and
controls. |
|
| 3. | Brain damage: the connection between brain
functions and sexual disturbances are complicated. The Kluver-Bucy or
temporal lobe syndrome (hypersexual behaviour with decrease in anger and
fear) was observed in human beings after removal of bilateral anterior
temporal lobes.13 On the other hand, temporal lobe epileptic
patients often have hyposexuality with reduction in libido and genital
functions, though a few had episodes of hypersexuality, especially after
the abrupt termination of seizure.14 Furthermore, patients
with varying degrees of dementia (involving mainly the frontal lobe) often
exhibit disinhibited sexual behaviours e.g. genital exposure, compulsive
masturbation, etc.15 Although elderly paedophilia has been
attributed to senile dementia, the psychosocial factors of loneliness
and social isolation appear to be more important.16 |
|
| 4. | Substance abuse: many sexual offences,
noteworthy that of rape, were committed under the influence of alcohol,
partly due to the disinhibition effect of alcohol, and partly because
of the direct effect of alcohol on the aggression and sexual centres of
the brain.17 |
|
| 5. | Psychiatric disorders: Kafka18
found a high incidence of major affective disorders in male paraphilics,
as these behaviour could be regarded as sexual dysregulation, similar
to that of the eating dysregulation like bulimia nervosa. On the other
hand, paraphilics could be regarded as having obsessive-compulsive disorders
with sexual compulsions.19 Finally, psychotic patients may
carry out bizarre sexual acts while under the influence of their delusions
and hallucinations. |
|
| B. | Psychological | |
| There are many psychological
theories for different types of sexual deviations. For example, that for
child abuse and paedophilia, are very different from those for sado-mashochism.
The reasons behind rape, for instance, could be totally different from
those behind exhibitionism. Commonly accepted viewpoints are put forward
here, including classical and operant conditioning and social learning.
It should be noted that a lot of different psychological factors including
personality characteristics are often involved. It is very difficult to
lump them together without being over-simplistic. |
||
| 1. | Conditioning: in classical conditioning
the deviant sexual behaviour is somehow paired with a pleasurable stimulus
resulting in eroticised response, and perhaps internalised (to a fantasy)
and reinforced by masturbation excitement. Due to lack of reinforcement,
other normal sexual stimuli lose attraction and become extinguished, especially
if these acts were associated with unhappy events. Operant conditioning
further suggests that if the operant consequence of the deviant behaviour
is positive, the habit is strengthened and vice versa. An example is that
the negative result of an arrest of an exhibitionist may temporarily stop
his exposure until other factors reinstituted the behaviour. Laws and
Marshall20 added that habituated behaviour consists of "functionally
linked sequences of instrumental acts" with one sequence triggering the
next (chaining effect). |
|
| 2. | Social learning theory: the offender acquired
the deviated act by normal or faulty learning, i.e. observing and modelling
the actions of others who are being rewarded or punished. Nowadays, cognitive-developmental
theories are more prominent, and internal cognitions such as beliefs,
expectations, imageries and fantasies, etc. are discussed, which in turn
are influenced by past learning experience and socio-cultural factors.
The concept of cognitive distortions helps to explain the reasons why
the paraphilics sustain and even justify their sexually deviated behaviour.
For example, a paedophile would consider that the gestures of a child
are seductive acts directed towards him. |
|
| 3. | Psychoanalytic theory: perversion is the
result of regressive defences against the castration anxiety (a man with
the fear of castration if he develops heterosexual identification with
the father) and the Oedipal complex (an ambivalent relationship with the
care-taking "breast" mother) in early childhood. Sexual perversion is
a kind of hypertrophied primitive infantile sexual drive, a fixated libido
in a person who has failed to transform from infancy into adult genital
maturity.21 Freud defined sexual perversion as deviated sexual
aims. He regarded voyeurism as deviated looking, frotteurism and sexual
harassment as deviated touching, exhibitionism as deviated showing, etc.
|
|
| Neo-Freudians and others have since modified
Freud's theories to explain the sexual perversion, with less emphasis
on libido but more on relational or interpersonal difficulties. For example,
Fenichel22 regarded exhibitionism as a desire to expose the
genitals to counteract castration anxiety, but object-relational theorists
like Stoller23 considered this as a need to avenge the humiliation
by women and a means to regain maleness. Likewise, transvestism was viewed
as fantasising the mother possessing a penis, but object relation theorists
would view this as a kind of psychic maternal object.24 |
||
| Finally, the psychodynamic theorists discuss
how sexually deviated behaviour results from the influence of personal
characters in adjustment to life. For example, the neurotic character
may use the behaviour to enhance genital potency, while the narcissistic
character as a repair of self defects and past trauma, and the borderline
character as a sign of ego fragmentation and impulsive deficits.25
|
||
| C. | Social | |
| A variety of cultural, family
and social factors during the upbringing period contribute to the development
of abnormal sexual behaviour. Bancroft2 talked about the pull
and push factors and applied them to the development of human homosexuality.
Using this concept, one can compose a few such factors for paraphilics
(Table 3). |
||
| Table 3: Pull and Push factors for paraphilics |
Pull factors (towards deviated sex):
Push factors (from normal sex):
|
| Management Many patients with sexual deviations do not accept such treatment voluntarily, but are forced to do so by their spouses, family members or even by the law. Those who are motivated for help often have co-existing sexual dysfunctions such as erectile difficulties. Therefore, the motivation for change is often tinted, and a good doctor-patient relationship may not be easy to develop. However, motivation is a very important factor for success, and thus a multi-disciplinary approach with clear explanation about therapies is needed. First of all, the usual comprehensive psychosocial history is helpful to rule out any psychiatric disorder, be it organic or functional. Secondly, time should be spent in getting a detailed psychosexual history that covers the developmental, past and current sexual experience and practices. This usually includes sexual knowledge (and sources), gender orientation and gender role, normal and abnormal sexual behaviour, and the circumstances leading to sexual arousal (including the sexual stimulus needed as well as the mood and thinking at the time of sexual intercourse or masturbation). For example, a husband may just use masturbation in the toilet to release tension, while the wife must think of a romantic affair with a lesbian stranger before getting an orgasm during sexual intercourse. A penile plethysmography may be useful to clarify genuine sexual interests.26 Thirdly, additional information from the victim(s) and other witnesses must also be considered especially for a sexual offender. Last but not the least, the risk of violence and recidivism should also be assessed. If there is any underlying psychiatric disorder, e.g. an obsessive-compulsive disorder, the appropriate psychiatric therapies should be given. For example, Kafka18 had treated with success paraphilics with antidepressants; while Ward27 cured a man with bipolar affective disorder and a two-year history of transvestism with lithium. As regards more definitive treatment for sexual deviations, there are both medical and psychological therapies, and they should be differentially applied when treating each individual disorder. |
|||
A. |
Medical | ||
| 1. | Medications or hormones: these
are of doubtful use, with the purpose of decreasing libido. |
||
| a. | Anti-androgens: medroxyprogesterone acetate
(Depo-Provera) and cyproterone acetate (CPA) have been used in the U.S.
to treat paraphilics, especially those associated with hypersexuality
e.g. nymphomania in women. The medication reduces plasma testosterone
level, and researchers observed significant decrease in sexual tension,
fantasies and preoccupation.28 A major criticism is that though
the drive is reduced (during the treatment period only), the direction
of the drive is not. |
||
| b. | Other medication: Perilstein et al19
had successfully treated one patient with paedophilia, one with exhibitionism
and one with voyeurism/frotteurism, with fluoxetine. All these patients
denied that they were depressed. |
||
| 2. | Surgery: with similar purpose
in mind as using medications, but more drastic and permanent. |
||
| a. | Surgical castration (bilateral orchidectomy)
and stereotaxic psycho-surgery (tractomy and limbic leucotomy) has been
performed in the past, usually for repeated sex offenders especially that
of rape and paedophilia. But the results were unreliable, not to mention
the ethical dilemma involved for such irreversible procedures. For example,
Heim and Jursch29 found that 40% of castrated men continued
to have sexual intercourse years after surgery. Rieber and Sigusch30
reviewed the cases in Germany and concluded that there were too many deficiencies
in the procedure to be of use. |
||
| b. | "Revision surgery" (sex change
operations) is a more acceptable treatment for transsexualism, consisting
of penile resection or reconstruction, vaginal reconstruction, augmented
by hormonal therapies to boost up the secondary sexual characteristics.
|
||
| B. | Psychotherapies | ||
| 1. | Psychoanalytic therapy: early
therapists target in developing insight into the castration and oedipal
dynamics in personal development. Later, object relational therapists
aim at the interpretation of inner sexual fantasies of the person and
its relations with character development. By interpreting the transference
and the various defences within the therapeutic relationship, the patient
tries to develop a more mature and normal sexual relationship in life.
Some therapists would take a more active, directive approach to effect
behavioural and responsible changes in the patient. |
||
| 2. | Behavioural therapy: behavioural
therapists in the past used aversion therapy (often via electric shocks
to induce pain) to alter the perverted behaviour. Another approach, a
method sometimes called "covert sensitisation", is to train
the patient to pair up the deviant sexual desire with a noxious feeling
or thought (e.g. an arrest by a policeman). However, this only suppresses
the problem behaviour rather than eliminates it, and consent has to be
sought in advance. With the patient's cooperation, the technique of "orgasmic
reconditioning" can be employed. Firstly, the patient is asked to
masturbate with his deviated fantasy and when orgasm is imminent, to switch
to normal sexual fantasies. The ensuring orgasm becomes a strong reinforcer
for the new sexual behaviour. This point of switching is then brought
forward in subsequent sessions until the masturbatory orgasm can take
place with these normalised fantasies. Lastly, the procedure of masturbatory
satiation can be employed. Initially, the patient masturbates while fantasising
normal sexual activity, but is compelled to continue to masturbate (say
for another 50 minutes) while thinking about the deviated sexual scenes,
and any sexual excitement related to the deviant will be lost. |
||
| 3. | Cognitive therapy: in recent
years, more emphasis is placed in modifying the underlying deficits and
incompetence via various cognitive (and behavioural) techniques. The cognitive-restructuring
technique aims at identifying the faulty thinking of the patient and tries
to help him realise the impact of his behaviour on the victims. The self-control
techniques, such as thought-stopping, help the patient gain control over
his deviant feelings and acts. |
||
The above treatment modules
can be conducted individually and sometimes in groups, with the latter
having the additional benefits of group modelling and peer pressure for
change. In addition to the different therapies, relaxation exercise, stress
management training and interpersonal skills are sometimes used as adjunctive
measures to combat anxiety and stress which may have triggered off the
deviated behaviour. Other provoking factors, if found, should also be
tackled. As many patients learn about sex from pornographic literature,
proper sex education is often necessary, including information and skills
about normal sexual functioning. Indeed, it may be necessary to help the
patient in attaining sexual satisfaction through normal or socially acceptable
outlets. Quite often, marital/couple therapy is needed, and the spouse
is advised to shape the abnormal behaviour systematically into more acceptable
sexual activities. Group therapy is sometimes organised, especially for
sex offenders, and the participants learn through group processes and
pressure. |
|||
| C. | Legal treatment | ||
| Persons having sexual deviations
often perform in secret, and they try to hide their behaviour from others
especially their close relatives. When they are caught, they often deny
strongly at least some of their past acts. Therefore, it is not common
for the patients to seek help from their primary care doctors. However,
the relatives (especially the spouses and parents) do sometimes seek advice
about such deviated sexual behaviour from their general practitioners.
To these frontline doctors, they may face the dilemma of reporting the
patients when their sexual deviations break the law. |
|||
| In determining the criminality
of sexual offence, the presence of consent (and the capacity to consent)
is very important. There is also often an age limit factor to be considered.
Many patients are referred to treatment involuntarily, and their motivation
for change may not be genuine, and perhaps a conditional term such as
probation or parole may be useful to motivate the sex offender to change.
Unfortunately, the rate of recidivism is high, and long-term supervision
may be necessary. To the serious sex offender, confinement to an institution
maybe a sure way to stop the deviated behaviour, but is not really treating
the underlying psychopathology. |
|||
Conclusion The classification of sexual behaviour is often affected by changing social norms (such as the normalisation of oral sex and decriminalisation of homosexuality), and the commercial exploitation of sex in recent years sometimes makes deviated sexual behaviour appear normal. There should be a balance between the pros and cons of including a sexual behaviour pattern as an illness into the classification, and limits should be set to avoid over-inclusion of trivial and harmless sexual acts. On the other hand, sexually deviant patterns of life often influence the individual's choice of occupation, sexual partner, hobbies and other daily activities. Exposure of their behaviour sometimes results in a breakdown of relationships between friends, partners and even family, and may lead to bribery and other criminal behaviour. Recent advances in psychotherapy are beneficial to a number of perpetrators, and sometimes a trial of medication is justified. Legal penalty is not a curative measure, and a holistic approach with contribution from professionals of various disciplines with both therapy and rehabilitation is ideal to prevent recidivism. Finally, there remains an issue as regards the ethics in castrating criminals with refractory sexual deviated behaviour (e.g. paedophiles), for the sole purpose of protecting society. |
| Key messages
|
References
|